These votive cups are just average. Each were not the same shape and size. I used them as part of the centerpieces of my wedding (decorated each). They served the purpose and noone noticed the differences in each since they were at different tables, but these are definitely NOT quality, just simply "value" as stated.
I've purchased about six boxes of these from the store over the course of a few years. While I can't vouch for online purchases, the product for me is great. Cost-effective, and good enough to even make your own candles in.
Returning all 3 orders-quality was inconsistent-only first shipment arrived unbroken-2nd shipments arrived broken!